It only takes a minute to sign up. Can an apostate be forgiven by Allah? I'm asking because of the verse :. Sign up to join this community. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top. Home Questions Tags Users Unanswered. Ask Question. Asked 5 years, 8 months ago. Active 2 years, 8 months ago. Viewed times. I'm asking because of the verse : "Those who believe, then reject faith, then believe again and again reject faith, and go on increasing in unbelief,- Allah will not forgive them nor guide them nor guide them on the way.
Kilise 2, 2 2 gold badges 18 18 silver badges 46 46 bronze badges. James James 5 5 silver badges 11 11 bronze badges. Active Oldest Votes. Sign up or log in Sign up using Google.
Sign up using Facebook. Sign up using Email and Password. Post as a guest Name. Email Required, but never shown.
The Overflow Blog. Socializing with co-workers while social distancing. Featured on Meta. Community and Moderator guidelines for escalating issues via new response…. Feedback on Q2 Community Roadmap. Related 5. Hot Network Questions.
As we shall see, God forgives everyone who repents for their sins and believes in Jesus, no matter what sins they have committed. Here we have a riddle. It is the Holy Spirit who does the special work of drawing people to God for salvation.
It is to your advantage that I go away; for if I do not go away, the Helper will not come to you; but if I depart, I will send Him to you. The Holy Spirit is the one who convicts the world of sin and leads them to repentance. For there is no difference; 23 for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God, 24 being justified freely by His grace through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus.
Are Apostates from the Faith beyond Repentance?
My response is to point out that Hebrews is a forgery, intended to be passed off as a letter of Paul. Therefore it is not the word of God, but is rather a lie written by someone hoping to gain an audience by tricking people into thinking Paul wrote it. So who cares what that liar wrote? That is indeed the end of the matter.
As I said, people worrying about the passages in Hebrews fear that because they have committed apostasy, God will not forgive them. We can lay those fears to rest by quoting something the Apostle Paul actually did write, namely, Romans Once a person is justified through truly putting their faith in Jesus, they can never be lost. They may commit apostasy, but those who have truly believed in Jesus will always repent and return to Christ eventually.
Verses 4 and 5 are obviously describing someone who has become a believing Christian. Verse 6 goes on to say that if the believer commits apostasy, it is impossible to renew them to repentance, because apostasy is akin to crucifying Jesus all over again. And the person either will not repent because their rejection of God is so complete, or they cannot repent because God will not allow them to.
The claim of these verses is proven false by the many cases of believers who have committed apostasy, and then later did repent.
But more importantly, Hebrews is from a forged book and it contradicts the authentic writing of Paul in Romans This is another way of saying what was said in Hebrews In verse 26 we see a believer who rejects Christ for another faith. We are then told that such a person will not be renewed to repentance, but will suffer the vengeance of God.
And again, the claim of these verses is proven false by the many cases of believers who have committed apostasy, and then later did repent. Finally, there is a response that encompasses the blasphemy against the Holy Spirit and apostasy. As a Pauline Christian, I believe salvation is through faith alone, it does not depend on works.
Christians do not have to keep any law or commandment perfectly in order to enter heaven, all that matters is our faith in Jesus. This teaching is stated clearly in Romans For there is no difference; 23 for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God, 24 being justified freely by His grace through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus, 25 whom God set forth as a propitiation by His blood, through faith, to demonstrate His righteousness, because in His forbearance God had passed over the sins that were previously committed, 26 to demonstrate at the present time His righteousness, that He might be just and the justifier of the one who has faith in Jesus.
It is excluded. By what law? Of works? No, but by the law of faith. Is He not also the God of the Gentiles? Yes, of the Gentiles also, 30 since there is one God who will justify the circumcised by faith and the uncircumcised through faith. Certainly not!Can the sin of apostasy be forgiven and the excommunication lifted in a normal confession or is a bishop needed? Do thoughts of apostasy entail excommunication?
Thoughts cannot be excommunicable. Only external actions. Apostasy is the total repudiation of the Christian faith. Asking on internet forums will only drive your condition. Apostasy as an act in the external forum merits automatic excommunication under the current code of canon law. Latae Sententiae means automatic excommunication. Entertaining thoughts of apostasy, while sinful, bring no special canonical censure. The action must be followed through.
Moreover, we must differentiate between apostasy and heresy as well. Apostasy is abandonment of the Christian religion in favour of another religion or an opposed philosophical system. Heresy is defection from the Catholic Church into another Christian sect, such as a Protestant church. If one, not a cleric, religious, or academic, does follow through with apostasy or heresy, nothing is likely to happen in the way of formal censure.
Repenting of that apostasy, one can return to any priest, though the pastor of the parish where one lives is most preferable. Many bishops throughout the Western world have delegated such cases reserved to them to all pastors or even to all priests, so the best thing to do is to speak to the pastor about this matter, and to seek his advice. How can an apostate be forgiven? Moral Theology.
Forgiveness for blasphemy against the Holy Spirit and apostasy
JohnCatholic25 January 25,pm 1. PaulfromIowa January 25,pm 3. Barricade January 29,pm 4. Check Canon of the current code of canon law: Can. For official apologetics resources please visit www.Hebrews seems to indicate that someone who leaves the faith can never return. I was baptised and took communion, however, raised secularly since then and became a serious atheist.
I now am trying to return to Catholicism, but this passage is making me fear that it is too late for me. Is this true? Fear not. The Lord wants you back. And I would say that God can and does forgive any sin that is repented of, sorrowed over, and brought to the Keys of Confession. No sin except that which is not asked to be forgiven will be unforgiven.
Perhaps someone versed in Greek can shed some light on this. I would exhort you to go to Confession when you are ready and start attending Mass. Be at peace. Start going to mass. Go to confession. Meet with a priest. Ask lots of questions.
Apostasy meaning and definition (Hebrews 6)
I am happy for you!! Same with me. Although I never would have said I was an Atheist. I knew there was too much stuff about the universe, ghosts, etc.
Even still, God never fully let me go. I would suggest going to confession and confessing everything God puts on your heart. You will feel so much better. Yes, quite right. My answer was that the Church is absolutely not against forgiveness for apostasy.A correct view of the passage, however, will relieve one of needless concern. The Bible student may be assured that Hebrews does not conflict with any teaching elsewhere in the Scriptures.
First, one needs to understand something of the general theme of the book of Hebrews. This document is an inspired treatise by an anonymous author. The original design was to prevent Hebrew Christians from yielding to the influence of certain Jewish teachers, who would have them defect from the faith, and return to their original religious heritage. The book of Hebrews is replete with warnings to Jewish Christians who were in danger of falling from the faith. They were warned not to follow the destructive course of some of their ancestors, who succumbed to weaknesses, and so were not allowed to enter into the rest that Jehovah had prepared for them Heb.
A consideration of the latter portion of chapter 5, and the initial segment of chapter 6, reveals that many of these Hebrew Christians had become stagnant in the service of Christ. Note some of the traits they had developed. In fact, these Jewish Christians had regressed.
Hodges, They once were enlightenedthus had left the realm of darkness cf. Acts They had tasted the heavenly gift. Note this comment from an otherwise respected scholar.
And what of this. How terrible it is to be so enslaved to a theory as to have to resort to this sort of textual twisting cf. These people had been made partakers of the Holy Spirit cf. Acts ; Rom. Again we cite W. The Hebrew Christians had tasted the good word of God and the powers of the age to come. It is only by the most deceitful handling of the word of God cf.
They were children of God in spite of the fact that they had not grown to the point that was expected of them. What is the plight of one who has known and experienced the lovely blessings detailed in Heb. From the grace that had been bestowed upon them see Heb.
The answer to the question is this. It sounds so bleak. It is bleak! Any attempt to weaken the term is an exercise in futility. But, as our original question suggested, the passage does seem to conflict with so many other biblical texts that lavishly describe the unfathomable love and mercy of our wonderful and benevolent Maker. The key to the solution is to be found in the following phrase. The American Standard Version renders it as follows:.Can Apostates Repent and Return to God?
Posted Mar 23, by Michael L. Brown opens up the Scriptures.
Subscribe to RSS
Spiritual Growth. An apostate is someone who once embraced the truth and then in time proceeded to repudiate and denounce it entirely or embraced false doctrine and damning error. A truly saved person can only go astray for so long before God will restore them. They wont linger for years in an apostate condition.
Perhaps for a short time but how short is something we cannot know for sure. All we can do is witness and admonish the rest is in the Lords hands. But until they repent and are restored to biblical orthodoxy we must warn them of the dangers of remaining in such a state. Nowadays those who now embrace the perversity of the LGBTQ movement who were once defenders of the biblical doctrine of man, woman and marriage are definite examples of apostates. Let God be true and everyone a liar!
Seems to me that Dr. The former is backsliding and the latter "fallen away". There's a difference. So the standard Dr. Brown uses to say there are verses that are clean to the 1 in Hebrews that is unclear is not correct.
In fact, according to the overwhelming verses in the NT that exhort one to "hold fast", "remain until the end", "keep the faith", etc. If one falls away from the faith and rejects the Lord having once been saved, or in other words kicks the Holy Spirit outta their life after having been indwelt, they are doomed.
Let's not give people a false assurance. This is the same false assurance that people give when they tell others they can reject God and God will never give up on them. I once had a woman tell me that God showed her it usually takes 7x before one will get saved.
We are doing people a disservice and it is VERY unloving to tell someone they can continue to reject God until their last dying breath and God will be waiting.It is a willful, deliberate departure from God, and is never accidental. Apostates are hardened to the point of not being able to repent Hebrews ; If anyone repents God will forgive, but apostates cannot repent because repentance is not given to them Acts Apostasy is deliberately siding with the enemies of Christ Phil despite the knowledge of the gospel.
An apostate is an enemy of Jesus — someone who seeks to undermine the gospel. The greatest enemy of the gospel is not sin, but false doctrine — especially false doctrine that takes emphasis away from Christ and his atonement. Most of the NT was written to undo the effects of such false teaching. Most of the apostates mentioned in the bible were false teachers, not just casual backsliders.
Hebrews refers to them as adversaries. They were reneging on their faith and denying Christ. They were also siding with those who persecuted their colleagues for abandoning Judaism and embracing Christ. According to 2 Peter apostates have forsaken the right way. Peter gives the example of Balaam. He did not sin in ignorance but deliberately sided with the enemy of God against the people of God.
Hebrews warns us not to depart from the living God. An apostate is not a backslider. Someone can backslide from various things. You can backslide from the ministry you once held if you get your priorities mixed up. But backsliding can be temporary and does not imply a loss of salvation.
In fact the word backslide never appears in the New Testament. Apostasy on the other hand is permanent impossible to renew them to repentance. In 1 Tim Paul tells us that he obtained mercy for his pre-Christian sins because he acted in ignorance. Does this mean if we sin deliberately, God will not forgive us? Paul was referring specifically to his persecuting the church. He was an enemy of God, but was not considered an apostate because he did not have the knowledge of the gospel.
If he was enlightened and still continued to make himself an enemy of God, then that may have been considered apostasy and he would not have obtained mercy. Hebrews says if we sin willfully there is no more sacrifice for sin, but it refers to a specific sin — apostasy vs. There are some who would like to believe that it refers to just about any sin, but if it did, then what that means is once we commit one deliberate act of sin, we can NEVER be forgiven. Most of the sins we supposedly commit in weakness are in fact deliberate.
We had the conviction, yet we sinned. Besides, 2 Thess. Read it.